View this email in your browser

Sheffield Labour Left  - For Socialism

A bulletin for Labour Party Members who supported the direction the party moved towards under Jeremy Corbyn & John McDonnell.
Opposing racism, antisemitism and political Zionism.
Opposing all expulsions/exclusions targeting the left.

SLL E-Bulletin #40 29 November 2020

Report from a member of Hallam CLP

On Thursday 26 November Sheffield Hallam CLP members not only witnessed first-hand the very real and very damaging consequences of the new authoritarian style of the Starmer leadership but also experienced the impoverishment of the fundamental democratic principles on which the party should stand.
It quickly became obvious that members had turned out in high numbers for the CLP meeting because of concerns and contentions regarding the fundamental rights of free speech and debate within their party. The majority were clearly wanting to discuss the existential crisis currently at play within their party and the motions gave some opportunity for this. 
The initial mood was comradely and polite but expectant and focused. Initially members were met with topics which should have been re-scheduled given the gravity of the current situation. One has to wonder why they weren’t.
Finally, after nearly 2 hours, the meeting managed to arrive at the main focus of the evening ie: the motions. Of the six, like the play Macbeth, three were deemed to be ‘those that shall not be named’ and were ‘temporarily’ bypassed ‘for later’.
However, three were deemed uncontentious enough to be allowed to be heard. Surprisingly, given the crux of all the current tensions, one was in support the TUC Resolution on Palestine and one was to call for a vote of no confidence in David Evans, the man who had, merely hours before, dictated what could and couldn’t be discussed in the meeting.
Despite the diktat from above these three motions passed with clear majorities, indicating the political temperature of the room, the strength of feelings of the membership and their stoic resolve to openly challenge the Kafkaesque attempt to block freedom of thought and speech. 
Throughout the meeting time was either lost or stolen from the main items on the agenda and contributing to this loss, ironically, was the mismanagement of votes cast asking for time extensions. Filibustering tactics by a minority, which the chair too frequently allowed, and naivety from some on the left, caused frustrations to grow and the spectacle reached its crescendo with claims that the meeting was over time, despite members having voted 55 to 19 to hear the other three motions. This action brought demands from the members for the chair to hear the shelved ‘banned’ motions.  The host (who clearly opposed hearing the motions) then begin to mute all members as they spoke and the chair simultaneously declared the meeting over and ejected everyone by having the host shut down the virtual room.
Members in the meeting openly declared that already their membership “hung by a thread” or that having voted for the new leadership, they now were worried and dismayed by the current actions and the effects these actions were having on the party.

Evans the Enforcer

Starmer’s efforts to exert control over the party has seen CLPs on the end of autocratic interventions over any motions that challenge the leader’s narrative. But it is his enforcer, General Secretary David Evans, who has been at the forefront of such anti-democratic moves.
But what do we know about Evans?
While it is clear he has form for wanting to stifle democracy and come down hard on anyone left of Tony Blair.
In 1998, a year after Blair came to power, Evans penned “The New Labour Party: A Vision for Organisational Modernisation” and a quick scan tells you that his behaviour is entirely in line with his politics.
He wrote: “Representative democracy should as far as possible be abolished in the Party. All members are equal, so there is no need for General Committees. These meetings would be replaced with dynamic policy forums, campaigning meetings and others as appropriate."
A clear sign of what is to come if he pursues these autocratic suggestions and turns CLPs into hollowed out bodies acting only as an extension of the national leadership.
And if you are in any doubt of what he intends, he went to say that CLPs should be run by an Executive elected at an annual all-member meeting and be able to control the local party for the next twelve months without being answerable to any democratically elected body.
A case that all members are equal, but some would be considerably more equal than others. 

Sheffield Labour Left

Sheffield Labour Left (SLL) is a network to help co-ordinate the genuine Labour Party left across the six CLPs covered by Sheffield.
We have a page on Facebook ( and our own website (, where you can find an archive of our first 35 bulletins.
We are connected to no other group, but work alongside others whose aims we share to see elected a socialist-led government.  In July 2019 we affiliated to the Labour Left Alliance:
Want to get involved with SLL or become a member? Contact us at the email address below.

Local labour movement meetings and events in December:
Tuesday 1 December:  South Yorkshire Migration and Asylum Action Group (SYMAAG) AGM.  
Olivia Blake MP is a guest speaker on resisting the hostile environment. To receive login details for the zoom meeting email us at  7.00pm start.  Zoom meeting.
Thursday 10 December:  Sheffield Hallam CLP Annual General Meeting.  7.30pm start. Register from 6.30pm onwards.

Our mailing address is:
Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.

This email was sent to <<Email Address>>
why did I get this?    unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences
Sheffield Campaigning · 38 Headland Road · Sheffield, South Yorkshie S10 · United Kingdom

Email Marketing Powered by Mailchimp